Seller guides
Offers & negotiations
Review offers, multiple bids, counters, conditions, certainty vs price, and after acceptance.
16 min read · Updated June 21, 2026

When an offer arrives, you are not just looking at a price — you are looking at a full Agreement of Purchase and Sale (APS): deposit, closing date, conditions, inclusions, and timing. Each term affects your net proceeds and how likely the deal actually closes.
Your listing agent presents every offer, explains the risk of each condition, and advises on accept, reject, or counter. You make the final decision. In multiple-offer situations, the highest price is not always the best choice — a firm offer with a larger deposit may beat a higher conditional bid.
This guide covers single offers, bidding wars, counters, and what happens after you accept.
Seven stages from offer to accepted deal
Typical GTA resale — your agent manages presentation; you approve every decision.
Prepare before offers arrive
During listing
Strong marketing should include a conversation about offer strategy. Know your ideal closing date, whether you can accommodate a fast or slow close, and which conditions you prefer buyers to carry — financing and inspection are standard; sale of buyer's home adds risk.
Shortlist a real estate lawyer before offers arrive — not after. Unusual clauses need legal review before you accept or counter.
- Minimum acceptable price — write it down before emotion enters
- Closing date range that works for your next home or lease
- Inclusions confirmed — appliances and fixtures you expect to leave or take
- Lawyer contact ready for same-day review on offer night
Receive and register offers
Offer day
Buyers submit offers through their agents to your listing agent. Each offer is registered with time stamp when multiple offers are held to one presentation date. Your agent confirms receipt and keeps you updated as deadlines approach.
Do not deal directly with buyers or their agents — all negotiation goes through your listing agent to protect strategy and agency rules.
- Irrevocable period — how long you have to accept, reject, or counter each offer
- Complete signed APS required — incomplete offers get less consideration
- Deposit cheque or proof may accompany offer — confirm amount and form
- Stay reachable — counters expire on tight clocks
Review a single offer line by line
Offer presentation
Price is the headline. Read the rest with your agent: deposit amount and due date (GTA norm often 5% within 24 hours of acceptance), closing date and possession time, conditions and their deadlines, chattels and fixtures included, and any special schedules.
Compare the offer to your list price and to recent solds in your pocket — not to what you hoped the home was worth when you bought it.
- Purchase price — gross number before adjustments and credits
- Deposit — larger deposits signal commitment; held in listing brokerage trust
- Conditions — financing, inspection, status certificate (condos), sale of buyer's property
- Closing date — must align with your move and next purchase
- Inclusions — fridge, washer, window coverings — confirm explicitly
Multiple offers — compare the full package
Offer night common in GTA
When several buyers want your home, your agent may hold offers to one date and time. Each offer is summarized on a comparison sheet. You may accept one, counter one, or reject all — there is no obligation to pick the highest price.
Some sellers request a best-and-final round — buyers improve once. Your agent advises whether that fits market norms and your timeline.
- Net certainty — firm vs conditional often matters more than $10,000 on price
- Deposit size and timing — weak deposit on high price is a red flag
- Closing flexibility — your preferred date may tip a tie
- Fewer conditions — inspection waived is buyer's risk; financing waived is yours if they cannot close
- Bullying clauses and custom schedules — lawyer review before you sign
Counter-offers — change one thing at a time
Same day to 48 hours
A counter changes the buyer's original offer — they can accept, reject, or counter back. Keep counters focused: price, closing date, or a single condition change. Long chains frustrate buyers and kill momentum.
Set a clear irrevocable time on your counter so negotiations do not drift. Your agent communicates counters in writing through the buyer's agent.
- Counter price — know your walk-away before you counter up from a low offer
- Counter closing — sometimes worth more than another $5,000
- Request larger deposit or shorter condition periods instead of only higher price
- Reject cleanly if terms are unacceptable — do not counter insultingly low offers without strategy
Accept and open the conditional period
Upon acceptance
Once both parties sign, you have a conditional or firm deal depending on what the buyer wrote. Standard conditional period is 5–10 business days for financing, inspection, and lawyer review. The buyer's deposit is delivered to trust per the APS timeline.
Cooperate with inspections and status certificate access — blocking access gives buyers lawful exit and wastes your marketing time. Complete agreed showing access for re-inspection if repairs are negotiated.
- Buyer inspection — you may be asked to leave; consider pre-listing inspection to reduce surprises
- Repair negotiations — credits or fixes before closing; document in amendments
- Financing failure — buyer exits under condition if APS allows; deposit returned per wording
- Notify your lawyer same day — they review the accepted APS immediately
Firm deal — conditions waived
5–10 business days after acceptance typical
When the buyer waives all conditions, the deal is firm. Both parties are legally committed to close on the closing date. Plan your move, order mortgage discharge, and complete any agreed repairs before closing.
If a buyer tries to renegotiate after inspection without a valid condition, your agent and lawyer protect your position — firm means firm.
- Mark closing date and possession time on calendar — often 6:00 p.m. on closing day
- Begin move planning and utility cancellation timing
- Next guide: seller closing — lawyer, discharge, and handover
- Relist only if deal collapses under a valid condition — your agent handles paperwork
Understanding buyer conditions — seller risk
- Financing condition — buyer exits if lender declines; standard and reasonable in most markets
- Inspection condition — buyer may request repairs, credit, or walk away; expect negotiation mid-period
- Status certificate — condos; buyer or lawyer reviews; rarely blocks sale on healthy buildings
- Sale of buyer's property — buyer must sell their home first; higher fall-through risk; weigh against price premium
- Firm offer — no conditions; buyer committed; inspection risk shifts to buyer if waived
- Short condition periods — less exposure for you; common in competitive offers
Choosing between price and certainty
Example: Offer A is $50,000 above Offer B but conditional on selling the buyer's current home. Offer B is firm with a 5% deposit and your preferred closing date. Offer B may net more certainty and close on time — Offer A may fail three weeks in and send you back to market.
Your agent quantifies risk — not just dollars — so you choose with eyes open.
Before offer night — seller checklist
Complete during listing so you are ready when offers arrive.
Offer review checklist
For each offer — use with your listing agent's comparison sheet.
Multiple-offer presentation checklist
When two or more offers arrive on the same date.
After you accept — seller checklist
Negotiation mistakes sellers regret
- Taking highest price without reading conditions — deal fails during buyer's sale-of-home
- Countering every low offer — burns time while DOM grows
- Verbal side deals on inclusions — disputes at walkthrough
- Refusing all inspection requests on principle — buyers walk under condition
- Not having a lawyer on offer night — unusual clauses signed in haste
- Celebrating before conditions waive — not closed until firm
- Dealing directly with buyer — undermines agent and agency rules
Related guides
- Book a listing consultation
Discuss offer strategy before you list
- Marketing your home
Getting offers to the table
- Pricing your home
Price strategy before offer night
- Closing the deal (seller)
After conditions waive — lawyer and possession
- The home selling process
Full Ontario seller timeline
- Making an offer
Buyer-side view — what is in their APS
Wondering what your home is worth?
Savie Wander can prepare a tailored value estimate for your home — free and no obligation.